Shingeki no Kyojin = (Shadow of the Colossus + Evangelion) / 2

Well played, Shinobu Kaitani, well played. Bringing Liar Game back from hiatus as soon as it got the Baka-Raptor Bump. A brilliant strategy befitting the creator of Liar Game.

Or so I thought.

Liar Game’s scanlating group announced it would delay the latest chapter of Liar Game in favor of some other manga I’d never heard of. One could only assume this was a profound lapse of judgmeHOLY SHIT.

Any manga with sustained popularity despite character designs this ugly (detailed ugly, not lazy ugly or “artistic” ugly) has to be good. I must warn you, however, the manga occasionally pulls a bait & switch with the ugliness for moé.

SnK is about humanity’s last stronghold trying to fend off giants that have already devoured 99% of the world population. Unlike all the giants with feelings in other anime, the SnK giants aren’t “people too”; they’re uninhibited killing machines. The balance of fear and awe they inspire most reminds me of Shadow of the Colossus, though they’re generally not as majestic. I’m also reminded a bit of Evangelion, not because of some boring religious symbolism or coming-of-age subplot, but because it has giant monsters that are trying to kill everyone, which is the true meaning of Evangelion.

Current Grade: ++

(With +++ potential.)

Tags: , , , , ,

29 people love sucking up to me

  1. feal87 says:

    Oh god, I generally decide what manga to buy from the covers, but hey this is a trap!
    After this one, I’ll definitely give a look at the content as well… 😐

  2. VucubCaquix says:

    Oh hey, I remember bateszi was raving about this manga a while back. With you too, maybe I should finally pick it up.

  3. hikaru says:

    “Any manga with sustained popularity despite character designs this ugly (detailed ugly, not lazy ugly or “artistic” ugly) has to be good”

    Read this and wondered which category DMC fit into.

  4. kluxorious says:

    holy fuck that was gruesome. Thank god the giants didn’t have penises, that would have traumatized me even more.

  5. Reed says:

    I thought you hadn’t watched Evangelion. I’ll read this if you read Yankee-kun to Megane-chan.

  6. Valence says:

    Why’s he fighting that muscleman in the opening image?

    *snare drum*

    • Baka-Raptor says:

      The giant was just minding its own business when a wall defending mankind’s last city showed up and started breaking itself on the giant’s foot. For some reason the humans assumed this was all the giant’s fault and tried to kill it.

  7. Mushyrulez says:

    So uh apparently it won the Kodansha Manga Award which apparently means something.

    Still dunno if my body/mind is ready to, uh… see that kind of stuff happen.

    • Baka-Raptor says:

      I suppose it may have won a few awards here and there, all of which are trivial in view of the Baka-Raptor Seal of Approval. Insert crappy MS Paint job here.

      Your body/mind has plenty of time to get ready. Releases are monthly, so it probably won’t finish for another decade.

  8. gan says:

    Hey Baka Raptor,so you’re finally back from hiatus from anime/manga is it?
    Anyways I recently got in to this manga and it’s indeed very good. I guess it’ll be the next hit like Fullmetal Alchemist (which has some similarities like the military theme). And the characters are great too,Mikasa is one of the most badass female leads out there.
    I was wondering why this series hadn’t caught your attention yet,but it seems I was wrong 😛
    And it’s definitely +++ material!

    • Baka-Raptor says:

      I’m only on hiatus from anime. Manga’s still on the table.

      Shadow of the Colossus and Evangelion were just the first two titles to come to mind. To cover my bases, I could probably cite FMA and Berserk as well.

      I blame it on the title. There’s nothing about “Shingeki no Kyojin” that grabs my attention. If they called it “Attack of the Titans” or something to that effect, I surely would’ve noticed it earlier.

      • Free Radical Prions says:

        “I blame it on the title. There’s nothing about “Shingeki no Kyojin” that grabs my attention. If they called it “Attack of the Titans” or something to that effect, I surely would’ve noticed it earlier.”

        Funny man.


        Also I noticed you compared this to Berserk. I’m guessing in terms of realistic art style and low fantasy, as well as ‘significant character’ body count, right?

  9. Free Radical Prions says:

    A friend of mine recommended this to me and I blazed through it in a few days. I should have known he saw it here. What really scares me is that on the phone with him, I also compared this manga to Shadow of the Colossus as well, except that it lacked the sense of “Wonder” and the “Grand” nature that Colossus has. This world is blatantly Low Fantasy, and the people live huddled in terror. Regardless, I’m so glad something like this is razing and plundering its way to the top of the sales charts. I’m so fucking tired of manga where all the characters get off scott-free regardless of what danger they’re in. I miss LOGH sometimes, where 87 people can be introduced in the first 5 minutes of an episode, you come to know and love around 47, and then 38 of the ones you gave a shit about died. That’s what I call war. Anyway, you’ve probably heard enough of all this before so I’ll get straight to it.

    I’m taking bets on the next 3 significant deaths, in this order; Christie, Reiner, and the Scout Commander.

  10. Kagamihime says:

    I read this after seeing your post and it wasn’t too bad. The art was a bit distracting but it’s not like it detracted from the story or anything. Anyway it reminds me of this new manga that’s out called Kamisama no Iutoori. It has a bit of the “artistic ugly”, but gets really good for some reason I can’t seem to grasp. Was wondering if you would check it out and see if it’s as underrated as everyone including myself believes.

    • Baka-Raptor says:

      Just checked it out. So far so good, but with only 11 chapters out I’ll reserve judgment for later. Just to be clear, I read this one, not this one, this one, or this one.

      • Kagamihime says:

        Then you read the right one. I wouldn’t recommend cliche shoujo crap unless it reaches lengths of so crappy its funny or pretty okay. I must say my fav part of that manga has to be Amaya. He isn’t your standard bat shit crazy person, but instead has his own potential to be epic for the weirdest reasons.

  11. Dudebro says:

    This sounds an awful lot like Gantz after it actually got a story direction going and with a whole less interesting concept.

  12. […] like a threat at all and that’s all the action consists of. Well, except for the giants of Shingeki no Kyojin or some aliens from Gantz maybe, since those are threatening, but those are a different […]

  13. […] manga is already described by some of the best internet scribes as being fucking awesome, nay, one of the best manga out there, and now THIS comes out. […]

  14. […] True to anime, there were a bunch of random people popping up behind the bushes. I wonder if they knew we were cosplaying Kuroko’s Basketball. Based on my height relative to everyone else’s, we could’ve been mistaken for Attack on Titan. […]

  15. […] inspired Attack on Titan. I liked Attack on Titan before it was popular. Less importantly, Muv-Luv descended from Kimi ga Nozomu […]

Leave a Reply

Back to how much I rule...